MabiPro: The Authentic Old-School Mabinogi Experience

i would love it guys added them becuase helps a lot for gathering book pages ect especialy such small server

Well there's a reason why enchants and some book pages can expire. It's to make them rare. If you remove that, it's basically changing the game balance.
Skills and enchants difficult to obtain (and valuable) wouldn't be as difficult to get anymore. Yet it's already far easier on this server due to double drop rate so I believe there's no need to make it easier (that's my personal opinion at least).
I can understand the frustration of finding AR8 and let it expires because you can't find AR7 but that's part of the game and "fun".

lol ok red just giving ideas because tbh as far seen server population is small so was just thinking wouldn't be bad make more people want to play

you also have double drop rate pots on top of that.
_________________________
Discord: Tonkatunk#7079
https://github.com/Tonkatunk/Mabi-Pro-Lazyfae-Mods

Don't worry I'm not attacking you ^^ Giving suggestion is perfectly fine and other might agree with your ideas.
It's just that I give my opinion on that matter. I don't think a low population should lead to a nerf of any kind. We already have double rates (ap, exp, skill training, drops, ...) to promote playing on this server without spending too much time building a new char.

Would be easier to just remove limited duration on Skill pages.

That keeps enchants rare and powerful, but doesn't massively hinder people from getting skills.

Honestly, when it comes to pages, the whole "They expire for challenge" or "Because they're magic" has always been the most BS. Nothing lore wise can ever explain why they expire, and making them expire doesn't add challenge to getting them. Most, if not all pages (aside from shock) are somewhat easy to get. You'll mostly never run the content that drops them until you're actively hunting the pages, and anytime you do before hand, you'd either ignore the hell out of the page, or take 5 seconds to ask global if anyone needs it, and no one will 99% of the time with this low pop, drop it back on the ground and be on your way. It really adds nothing to make them expire, especially the much rarer ones that are actually time consuming as hell to get.

That said, them expiring, and enchants, aren't so bad. The real issue is with their tiny expiration window. A few hours may seem like a lot, but when you realize your friend or that one guy you got the page/enchant for in the first place is gone for the day, away from their comp, then there's nothing you can do.

If I had actually found Frutties enchant we'd been hunting for for the past 3 days of spamming the ever living hell out of TOA on the two days he wouldn't be around, I'd be so fucking pissed.

Idk, my post is all over the place. Remove skill page timers or increase the duration 2-3x. Enchants, just double the time.

Wel, so far I've found shock 2,3,4,6,8,9 and 10 atleast once, very usefull right when u can't save those for later use.