MabiPro: The Authentic Old-School Mabinogi Experience

Semi-Necroposting instead of making my own thread for this exact suggestion, but the stack size increase from 10 to 50 sounds like the bare minimum for what should happen to 2x2 Ore. Another place to look might be to have Ore Piles by default feature a chance at multiple ores like Metallurgy does, if this is something that's possible. And given that it's already inherently less convenient, I'd wager that a chance of 1-3 ores without any Life Skill attached would render mining far from overpowered.

Poll it, or something.

While randomized color permutations exist in stores resetting every night at midnight, there doesn't appear to be a way for us to change the colors of existing gold and item bags, being particularly unfortunate for our Item Bag(150) we receive upon creating our character, whose colors appear set in stone... for now.

If it's within reason (and easily implemented), I'd quite enjoy the ability to dye Gold Pouches, Item Bags, Alchemy Crystal Bags, and perhaps even Bolt / Arrow/Javelin stacks. But mostly the Item Bag(150).

As long as the accuracy change is reflected in Throwing Attack, too.

Aha, shows how long it's been since I played a Giant. My bad.

Time to buy some Mana Preservation Stones, bub.

no

Proposing:

Wheat Flour
change ingredients from 10 Wheat to either 5 Wheat or 2 Wheat
make stackable to at least 5 (currently unstackable)

Barley Flour
change ingredients from 10 Barley to either 5 Barley or 2 Barley
make stackable to at least 5 (currently unstackable)

Wheat
increase stack size from 5 to 10 (this is something Live Mabi has done)

Barley
increase stack size from 5 to 10 (this is something Live Mabi has done)

Windmill (skill)
no changes requested

Windmill (production station)
Enable auto-production (currently you are only able to create one Flour at a time)

the solution is to make mana preservation stones better, not to gut the mechanic

I suppose one thing I'd say would help would probably be increasing the stack size of Mana Preservation Stones to something higher than 10.

Maybe also buffing the existing Mana Evaporation reduction upgrades we have SIGNIFICANTLY, since they're super terrible (doubly so because they're not only pretty ineffective at ultimately keeping your mana when you swap off, but also because in doing so you're sacrificing other upgrades that get you places).

As far as I can tell, Wheat Flour and Barley Flour are exclusively used for Cooking. It should only have an effect on how much of a nightmare it is to make a large quantity of Flour for use in the Cooking skill. 10 Wheat just for a fairly low success rate on milling flour (around 74%) is just a huge pain in the ass.

Don't forget that Homesteads are, by design, literally anti-content. They exist solely to disincentivize actually playing the game.

the problem with this line of thinking is you're "worrying" about a situation where things return to how they are now, and pleading that this not be implemented. do you genuinely not realize that there's literally nothing to lose if this gets added?

no

the stack for 2x2 ore could be 100 and it would still be worse than metallurgy. for mining to even come close to "equivalent" pickaxes or the ore piles themselves need looking at. this will just make it less moronic when you get ore from fragmentation

Turning 30 MP into 100 MP is just so inefficient, y'all. Same goes for turning 50 into 200 and 100 into 300.

just because you don't feel like utilizing the alternative doesn't mean a mechanic needs to be removed

if a 1x1 item that stacks to 100 kills your inventory i think you have bigger problems. this sort of change would be pointless

wasting a finest cuilin on an elemental crystal with a minor buff would need to yield at least 500 crystals to be worth it. ultimately the problem with your idea is that you have the damage boosts increasing at a static pace rather than a damage boost proportionate to the difficulty of actually aquiring the cuilin stones. on water, for example, with +5, +10, +15 and +20, it's just not worth burning the good cuilins on it. you'd be best just using the low-grades and commons you have no choice but to collect on them while saving the higher-grades for golems. if you wanted to have boosts proportionate to the actual value of the cuilins, we'd need to be talking a damage boost growth closer to +3, +7, +17, and +35.

and even then, it doesn't really feel thematically appropriate to just flush cuilin stones into an oven to make your crystals better, because it sort of ignores what the crystal-making process even entails. the cuilin stones are the golem, not a catalyst for generating energy.


Summon Golem


if you think fire is weaker than water you aren't thinking at all. even ignoring the critical hit properties it's downright stupid to not recognize that a damage boost applied over 3 hits of Flame Burst is better than one applied to a single hit of Water Cannon.

I think we'd be much better off if Stones of Sliab Cuilin were made into a mission worth running and mining for cuilins in than just arbitrarily creating a higher demand for something that's still abysmally unfun to gather.

Cuilin Stones don't need to be "done justice". They're just rocks. Melting them down into elemental crystals for a damage buff makes about as much sense as melting down Dead Bees for a damage buff would.

spoken like someone who's never collected ancient books

get over it, 10 1x1 slots isn't "held hostage", drama queen.