i encourage you to check out my thread on gm overmoderation, as i feel it is relevant to the issue of low server population. (obviously, it's not the only issue but the reason i and my guild, as well as several other guilds have emptied out. maybe some people consider us "bad people," but i strongly disagree and believe we as a group, ie. all the people spurned by hair-trigger moderation, brought a lot of life to the server.)
apparently, a tos change is coming soon, but overmoderation has ran off a lot of potential users over the server's lifespan that wouldn't have left otherwise. i'm not rallying for toxicity, but gms shouldn't be involved in interpersonal drama and that's the gist of that thread. it's already a small game, it doesn't need to be made even smaller by further removing some people others deem "problematic." just use your blacklist! all the different kinds of people - good and bad - are what made mabinogi what it used to be!
thanks!